Newton's third law, and why the forces never cancel
The action–reaction pair acts on two different bodies — the single idea that decides most marks in this chapter, with recoil and rocket numericals worked out.
The statement
To every action there is an equal and opposite reaction.
Every word matters, but one thing is missing from that sentence and it is the thing examiners test: the two forces act on different bodies. Write the law and then add that sentence, because it is what the rest of the chapter depends on.
When you push a wall with 50 N, the wall pushes your hand back with 50 N. Equal in magnitude, opposite in direction, acting along the same line — but one force acts on the wall and the other acts on your hand.
Why they do not cancel
Two forces cancel only when they act on the same body. An action–reaction pair never does, so it never cancels.
Think about a boy pushing a boat away from a jetty:
- The boy pushes the boat forward with force F. That force acts on the boat, so the boat accelerates forward.
- The boat pushes the boy backward with force F. That force acts on the boy, so the boy accelerates backward.
Two different bodies, two different accelerations. Nothing cancels. If action and reaction did cancel, nothing in the universe could ever accelerate — which is the neatest way to answer "why don't they cancel?" in one line.
Where you see it
Walking. You push the ground backward; the ground pushes you forward. On ice you cannot push backward effectively, so you cannot walk.
Swimming. You push the water backward; the water pushes you forward.
A rocket. Hot gases are pushed out downward; the gases push the rocket upward. A rocket does not need air to push against — a common misconception, and a good exam question.
Recoil of a gun. The gun pushes the bullet forward; the bullet pushes the gun backward.
A boat and the jetty. Step off a small boat carelessly and it slides away behind you.
Momentum makes the numbers work
Conservation of momentum is the third law written another way. In an isolated system the total momentum before equals the total momentum after.
Notice the forces on bullet and rifle are equal, but the accelerations are not, because the masses differ by a factor of 200. That is why the bullet leaves at 400 m/s and the rifle nudges back at 2 m/s.
Show answer
Total momentum before = 0, since both are at rest.
After: (50)(4.2) + (70)(v) = 0
210 + 70v = 0
v = −3 m/s
The heavier skater moves at 3 m/s in the opposite direction. The lighter skater always ends up faster, which matches everyday experience.
Answering the standard questions
"Why does a gun recoil?" The gun exerts a forward force on the bullet; by the third law the bullet exerts an equal and opposite force on the gun, pushing it backward. Momentum is conserved, so the gun's backward momentum equals the bullet's forward momentum.
"A horse pulls a cart. The cart pulls the horse back with an equal force. How does the cart move?" This is the classic. The pair acts on different bodies. What moves the cart is the pull of the horse on it; what moves the horse is the reaction of the ground on its hooves, which exceeds the backward pull of the cart. Answer it by listing the forces on each body separately.
"Can a single force exist alone?" No. Forces always occur in pairs.
The mistakes to avoid
Saying the forces cancel. They cannot, because they act on different bodies.
Naming a pair that acts on the same body. Check every pair you write with the question "on which body does this act?".
Forgetting to convert grams to kilograms in momentum questions. 20 g is 0.02 kg, and getting that wrong scales your answer by a thousand.
Dropping the direction. Momentum is a vector. State the sign or say "in the opposite direction" — an answer of "2 m/s" without direction is incomplete.
Stuck on this in your own textbook?
Ask our tutor about this chapter and get an answer drawn from the book your board actually prescribes, with the passage cited.
Try a lesson free